Darren Criss

Raphael (voice)

Scott Menville

Donatello / Pirate #1 (voice)

Eric Bauza

Leonardo / Pirate (voice)

Townsend Coleman

1980's Michelangelo / Pirate Captain (voice)

Greg Cipes

Michelangelo (voice)

Jessica McKenna

April O'Neil / Pirate April (voice)

Brian Bloom

Shredder (voice)